Jerin maganganun da aka tattara kuma aka yi bincike a kansu daga jami'an Isra'ila da manyan mutane da aka ambata a matsayin shaida ta niyyar kisan kiyashi, galibi daga yaƙin Gaza. Kowace magana tana da hanyar haɗi zuwa tushenta na rikodi kuma tana nuna ko an tabbatar da ita da ainihin asalin ta. Kisan kiyashi, a doka, yana buƙatar niyyar halaka wata ƙungiya, gaba ɗaya ko wani ɓangare, don haka (Yarjejeniyar Kisan Kiyashi, 1948, Mataki na II).
Waɗannan kimantawa mahallin ne. Babu ɗayansu da ke shigar da maki na ƙasa.
| Kwanan wata | Jiki | Sakamako | Majiya |
|---|---|---|---|
| 26 Jan 2024 | Kotun Ƙasa da Ƙasa ta Shari'a, Afirka ta Kudu v. Isra'ila, matakan wucin gadi | Ya sami da'awar haƙƙoƙin da aka yi ƙarƙashin Yarjejeniyar Kisan Kiyashi a matsayin mai yiwuwa kuma ya ba da umarni. Ya ambaci kalaman Gallant, Herzog da Katz (¶¶50–54). Ba hukunci ba ne cewa kisan kiyashi na faruwa; ƙarin umarni a 28 Mar da 24 May 2024. | Umarni, 26 Jan 2024 · 28 Mar · 24 May · shafin shari'ar |
| Mar 2024 | Mai ba da rahoto na musamman na Majalisar Ɗinkin Duniya kan yankin Falasɗinawa da aka mamaye, "Anatomy of a Genocide" | Dalilai masu ma'ana na gaskata cewa an cimma ma'aunin da ke nuna kisan kiyashi. | A/HRC/55/73 |
| 5 Disamba 2024 | Amnesty International | An yanke hukuncin cewa Isra'ila ta aikata kuma tana aikata kisan kiyashi a Gaza. | MDE 15/8668/2024 |
| 19 Dec 2024 | Human Rights Watch | Ayyukan kisan kiyashi da laifin cin zarafin ɗan adam na hallaka ta hanyar hana ruwa. | "Kashewa da Ayyukan Kisan Kiyashi" |
| 31 Aug 2025 | Ƙungiyar Ƙasa da Ƙasa ta Masana Kan Kisan Kiyashi | Shawara: manufofi da ayyukan Isra'ila a Gaza sun cika ma'anar doka ta kisan kiyashi (Mataki na II). | ƙudurin IAGS |
| 16 Sep 2025 | Kwamitin Bincike na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya mai zaman kansa | An yanke hukuncin cewa Isra'ila ta aikata kisan kiyashi a Gaza; an kawo maganganun Herzog, Netanyahu da Gallant a matsayin shaida ta niyya. | A/HRC/60/CRP.3 |
| 12 Jan 2024 – 16 Sep 2025 | Gwamnatin Isra'ila | Ya ƙi duk abin da ke sama. Ya gaya wa Kotun cewa maganganun da aka ambata ba su da tushe, an ciro su daga mahallin su, ko mutanen da ba su da ikon yanke shawara ne suka faɗe su, kuma manufofin yaƙinsa su ne lalata Hamas da dawo da waɗanda aka yi garkuwa da su, a matsayin kariya bayan harin 7 Oktoba 2023 (an kashe kusan 1,200, an sace 251). Ya kira rahoton Kwamitin Bincike "karkatacce kuma ƙarya". | ICJ verbatim record CR 2024/2 · amsa ga CoI (rumbun ajiya na UN) |
Don kwatance: Ma'aikatar Lafiya ta Gaza ta bayar da rahoton cewa an kashe fiye da 67,000 kafin tsagaita wuta na Oktoba 2025 (Isra'ila na jayayya kan adadin mayaƙa); wani bincike na kamawa da sake kamawa a The Lancet (Jamaluddine et al., 2025) ya kiyasta cewa an yi ƙasa da rahoton mutuwar da ta faru sakamakon rauni; kuma IPC ya tabbatar da yunwa a Lardin Gaza a ranar 22 ga Agusta 2025. Adadin waɗanda suka mutu ba shi kaɗai shaida ce ta niyya ba: mutuwar fararen hula da yawa na iya faruwa sakamakon rashin kulawa ko ƙarfin da bai dace ba, waɗanda laifukan yaƙi ne amma ba kisan kiyashi ba.
Buƙatar da Afirka ta Kudu ta shigar da ƙara (29 Disamba 2023) ta bayyana "alamun niyyar kisan kiyashi" a sashe na D, shafuka 59–67, ¶¶101–107, tare da bayanan ƙasa 439–506 da ke ba da ainihin rubutun, watsa shirye-shirye ko labarin. Kowace magana da ke ƙasa tana nuna matsayin mai maganar a ranar, ambaton, tushen rikodi, inda aka kawo ta da matsayin tabbatarwa. Ja = maganganun da aka kawo a matsayin shaida ta niyya. Kore = manufofin yaƙin Isra'ila, hujjojinta ga Kotun da maganganun kamewa, waɗanda aka ajiye kusa da su kamar yadda hanyar ta buƙata.
Ana lodawa…
Karanta wannan kafin lambobin. Waɗannan ƙididdiga ne na wucin gadi na maganganun Gaza 47 da aka ɗauko daga takardar kotu. Takardun cikin gida na Isra'ila kusan ba su samuwa gaba ɗaya, don haka ana ƙididdige maganganun jama'a ne kawai. Ma'aunin fihirisar bayyananniyar niyya da aka rubuta ne, ba "makin kisan kiyashi" ba, kuma ba ya yanke hukunci kan tambayar doka. Ana bayar da matakan daban kuma ba a taɓa haɗa su cikin lamba ɗaya ba.
Ana ƙididdige kowace magana S = (A/5) × (E/4) × T × O × (1 − R), daga 0 zuwa 1, inda A shine ikon mai magana, E yadda maganar ta fito fili, T ko tana nufin ƙungiyar ne ko mayaƙa kawai, O ko an bi ta da umarni ko ɗabi'a daidai, da R ko an yi watsi da ita. Ma'anoni suna a ƙasa. Ba a taɓa haɗa maganganun kamewa cikin S.
Bayanai 606 da zionism.observer (Databases for Palestine) ta tattara, an tattara su ranar 23 Satumba 2026. Kowanne yana da hanyar haɗi zuwa tushensa na asali da kuma hoton allo da aka ajiye na shafin. Ana nuna matsayin kamar yadda shafin yake lissafa su a yau, wanda ba koyaushe shine matsayin da mai magana ya riƙe a ranar ba. Bayanan da ba su cikin iyakar wannan rikodin (game da Lebanon, Iran ko Gabar Yammacin Kogin Jordan, marasa tabbataccen kwanan wata, ko na masu magana da ba su riƙe wani matsayi a gwamnatin Isra'ila ba) an yi musu alama ba su cikin iyaka tare da dalili.
Kowace sanarwa wata magana ce ko takarda mai kwanan wata ta wani mutum da za a iya gane shi, tare da ambatonsa da tushensa na rikodi. Ana auna ta bisa ma'auni biyar:
| Auna | Ma'auni | Abin da yake rubutawa |
|---|---|---|
| A · Hukuma | 1–5 | 5 firaminista ko shugaban ƙasa · 4 ministan majalisar ko babban jami'in tsaro · 3 babban hafsa ko ƙaramin minista · 2 ɗan majalisa ko jami'i mara ikon zartarwa · 1 mai yada labarai ko mutum mai zaman kansa. An ɗauka har zuwa ranar sanarwar. |
| E · Bayyananne | 0–4 | 4 kira ko shiri na lalata jiki · 3 kira na yanayin rayuwa mai lalata (yunwa, babu ruwa, cikakken lalacewa) ko ƙaura ta tilas · 2 laifin gamayya, ko musun cewa akwai fararen hula · 1 harshe na wulakanci · 0 babu |
| T · Manufa | 1 / 0.5 / 0.25 | 1 yawan jama'a gaba ɗaya · 0.5 ba a bayyane tsakanin jama'a da mayaƙa ba · 0.25 mayaƙa kawai |
| O · Aiwatar da shi | 1 / 0.6 / 0.3 | 1 tare da umarni, manufa ko ɗabi'a masu dacewa · 0.6 alaƙa ta wani ɓangare · 0.3 ba a sami alaƙa ba |
| R · An janye | 0–0.5 | 0 ba a janye ba · 0.2 mai magana ya ja da baya · 0.5 jihar ta amince da shi a hukumance |
Maki S = (A/5) × (E/4) × T × O × (1 − R), daga 0 zuwa 1. Ana jera maganganun kamewa da martanin Isra'ila gefen maganganun amma ba a haɗa su cikin makin.
An raba masu magana zuwa matakai uku, ana bayar da rahoto dabam: Mataki na 1, shugabancin ƙasa (firaminista, ministoci, shugaban ma'aikata, manyan hafsoshi) · Mataki na 2, sauran wakilan ƙasa (mambobin Knesset, hafsoshi da sojoji, masu magana da yawun gwamnati, jami'ai) · Mataki na 3, manyan mutane marasa muƙami ('yan jarida, masu watsa shirye-shirye, tsoffin jami'ai).
| Majiya | Abin da yake bayarwa |
|---|---|
| Afirka ta Kudu da Isra'ila, Buƙatar fara shari'a, ICJ, 29 Disamba 2023, sashe D (shafuffuka 59–67, ¶¶101–107, bayanan ƙasa 439–506) | Maganganu 47 da aka kawo a matsayin nuni na niyyar kisan kiyashi, kowanne da ainihin rubutunsa, watsa shirye-shiryensa ko labarinsa |
| Umarnin ICJ kan matakan wucin gadi, 26 Jan 2024, ¶¶50–54 | Kalaman Gallant, Herzog da Katz da Kotun ta ambata |
| Hujjar baka ta Isra'ila, rikodin kalmomi na ICJ CR 2024/2, 12 Jan 2024 | Martanin Isra'ila ga kalaman, da manufofin yaƙinta da ta bayyana |
| Kalaman gwamnatin Isra'ila: shawarwarin majalisar ministoci, Ofishin Firayim Minista, Babban Lauyan Gwamnati | Kalaman kamewa da takunkuman da aka jera gefen kalaman da aka kawo |
| zionism.observer (Databases for Palestine), an tattara 23 Sep 2026 | Ƙarin maganganu 606, 1930–2025, kowanne an haɗa shi da ainihin tushensa, yawancinsu da hoton allo da aka ajiye |
| Rahotannin kotuna da masu bincike da aka jera a sama | Mahallin; ba abubuwan shigar da maki ba |
Duk abin da ke wannan shafi, kamar yadda binciken ya wallafa, domin a iya sake rubuta shi da sake kimanta shi da kansa:
An gina shafin 2026-10-04. Ana maraba da gyare-gyare da fassarorin da ake jayayya ta shafin Ƙaddamarwa.